Vaughan Williams 2 – the London symphony

Posted In: Repertoire


  • Participant
    Alison on #240175

    Would you know whether this is usually performed with 2 harps or a single player, as there are solos for each and ‘a2’ too. It looks like one harp is sufficient.


    Participant
    Saul Davis Zlatkovski on #240393

    It is definitely meant to be doubled.


    Participant
    Alison on #240975

    Has anyone reset any of the chords and handfuls ? Note to Barbara Fackler – have you ? Sometimes there are chords clumped with 5 LH and 3 RH fingers, for example, let alone chromatic passages which could be spelt enharmonically for easier reading. The usual VW ‘discrepancies’…. !!


    Participant
    Elizabeth Volpé Bligh on #241107

    It should have two harps, because of some of the chords that have more than eight notes, but also at G in the second movement, where it is much better to split between two harpists. Also, in the third movement at H, the second harpist can play the bass octaves while the first harpist takes the chords. Since the chords are so wide, it would make sense for the second harpist to play the bottom section of the chords with the right hand while playing the octaves with the left. This is an exposed section. At 4 before K, and K, the harp parts can be split between the two players. I wrote out this section to avoid the page turn. (Attached.)


    Participant
    Saul Davis Zlatkovski on #241125

    Not only that, but it is clearly marked where it should be harp one only, which means there should be a second harp doubling the rest of the time. I don’t know it wasn’t printed as a Harps part, but it may have just been a typo. One should check the orchestral score and see if it says harp or harps.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.