Home › Forums › Teaching the Harp › Teaching youngsters to tune.
- This topic has 10 replies, 5 voices, and was last updated 2 years, 1 month ago by Alison.
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 12, 2019 at 12:19 pm #232290AlisonParticipant
How do you teach youngsters to tune in a way that is accessible and which future proofs their habits ? Really the question is which key should I ask youngsters to tune to – Eb with an electronic tuner and the levers off ( so they grapple with the true sharps being displayed), or in C with the levers on ? Should I take them through the 4ths and 5ths method or just say best to start at middle C (levers on) – tune downwards sequentially first and then upwards from middle D.
To future proof them for orchestra do they still need to start at 3rd A, or can that come later ? You see I’ll always start at 3rd A (Ab) with a pedal harp in order to tune in C (Cb) major. On lever harps I use the same method from 3rd C to tune in Eb major (levers down), but actually my tuning is also viable by ear as the steps are in 4ths and 5ths, having grown up without an electronic tuner and in fact I often tune by ear anyway as it’s quicker.
October 15, 2019 at 3:23 pm #232452TacyeParticipantTuning with the levers off is slightly better for the strings and levers, as well as giving better results (assuming the harp is well regulated). So I think this is very important. Teaching care for the instrument and all that. My tuner shows Bb and Eb, and I imagine there are tuning apps which can be set to show flats rather than sharps.
I see no great advantage to starting at 3rd A – I usually don’t when using a tuner. If I know the A isn’t going to be at 440 I will calibrate the tuner to it and then tune sequentially.
I doubt that tuning by tuner and later learning tuning by ear with different note order as a separate skill would cause confusion. A full tune by ear is a rare lifesaver in my playing – and I don’t think I ever taught it to anyone I would class as a youngster. But a rapid check on tuning or a tweak of a string or two by ear are much more common for me and I suggest worth teaching separately.
October 20, 2019 at 10:53 pm #233000Saul Davis ZlatkovskiParticipantI think tuning forks are the way to start, a B and an E or C and F. That way you can teach about fifths and overtones.
October 22, 2019 at 12:09 pm #233125evolene_tParticipantHi Alison,
Answering from the perspective of a student here. During my first class, my teacher taught me that the harp was tuned in Eb, and then I had to sharp the levers myself. Like Tacye said, it is better to tune the harp with all levers down to prevent an added tension in the small segment of string between the lever and the tuning peg.
To be honest, during those first few lessons, I just accepted that tuning as is, because I wanted to play the harp, not spend hours understanding music theory.That understanding came a little bit later : a few months in, perhaps. Having the correct tuning right away made it so much easier to understand!
I’ll admit, it wasn’t a straightforward process. At first, I played songs in C major, then got to think “Irish songs tend to be played with C and F levers up and not down”, and only later did I delve into theory, modes, intervals and such.This video makes it very easy for beginners to understand (and can be sped up easily) : Learn about Key Signatures and Scales for Lever Harp
Concerning the 4ths and 5ths method, I haven’t tried learning that way so I don’t know if it’s easier. It does help the student to connect to a sound, and not just a letter on an electronic tuner.
January 29, 2020 at 8:34 am #241095harpingdudeParticipantI just taught my 10yo student to tune her 34 string Voyager lever harp.
I start with the 3rd A and tune down the scale because she’s in orchestra. This harp has nylon strings and metal in the bass so I’m not to worried about wear and tear on the strings.
I use the Pano tuner app on my phone it shows a nice segment of green when the string is in tune.
I have the student practice tuning in my presence. It usually takes up to 30 minutes sometimes more. With follow ups in ensuing lessons.
The Voyager is a tall Instrument for a ten year old And the metal string tuning pins are difficult to turn, so I teach the parents as well.
The Pano tuner app uses flats instead of sharps as the semitone. That may be confusing to new students.
I try to save the theory for more advanced students because students are so easily confused in the beginning. There’s so much that is new that it’s easier if you just go with the basics.
Children and adults are alike in this respect. Adult learner’s want to do it all right now!!! But they are easily frustrated if you throw too much at them. So you have to pace them for their own good.
It’s better to tune their harps for them until they ask to be taught. It’s usually within the first few weeks of lessons.
An important 1st lesson to learn is if the note doesn’t change you’re probably on the wrong tuning pin. Also teach them to go flat and then raise the pitch to prevent broken strings(especially if they are on the wrong tuning pin.
That’s my 2 cents.July 19, 2021 at 9:37 am #257341BarbaraParticipantLooks Ike I’m the odd man out here, but I’d recommend teaching her to tune her harp in C with the levers down. (And don’t forget that a hand should always be on the tuning key when it’s on the harp!) However, find what works best for you and the student. 😀
I tend to teach students to tune in a circle of fiths…that also has the benefit of reinforcing a little theory. If you do decide to go the levers down, key of Eb route, I have a video & cheat sheet up for tuning a lever harp up that might help : https://www.fischarper.com/smp-review/.
In my own practice, I often tune starting on A(b), go down and then go back to the A and up.
Phew, I just gave you a really long-winded response. 🥳
August 4, 2021 at 6:56 am #258514Philippa mcauliffeParticipantHowever you teach them to tune I would make them bring their own harp to their lessons and check it and tune it while there. They are usually woefully out unless the parent is keen in my experience. I ask the parent to do it for the little ones anyway – they just want to play. Get them involved when they ask to do it or need to do it. The simpler the better at the very start so no levers and tune to C as a lot of people do know the C scale and/or have a piano. I give them music in C. White notes! I could tune my 34 string lever harp in any key and kept it in Eb when I was 10 but the pedal one was impossible until I got taller.
August 4, 2021 at 11:30 am #258518balfour-knightParticipantGood posts here! I agree, I would teach them to tune in the Key of C, especially if they are planning to move on to the pedal harp. E flat tuning should only be used when the student actually needs to play with other instruments in flat keys, or the music requires it. Even then, with this tuning, only three flats are possible, so the student might need to tune in A flat, D flat, G flat, or even C flat. Piano students generally begin in the Key of C, then progress to one sharp and one flat, etc. They would balk at the sight of three flats, if the method book started that way!
Happy harp tuning, everyone,
BalfourOctober 10, 2021 at 7:20 pm #260406Saul Davis ZlatkovskiParticipantAnd tuning forks will last forever, tuners will not. That said, my second-oldest Korg tuner is still my best one.
October 10, 2021 at 7:57 pm #260408balfour-knightParticipantI agree, Saul, I always fall back on my original tuning forks when tuning any of my instruments. They never waver, fail, run down, etc. like electronic tuners. However, I have a Korg professional one for setting the temperament much more quickly than I can with the tuning forks and by ear.
Cheers,
BalfourFebruary 16, 2022 at 10:21 am #283886 -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.