L&H Shamrock 34 or a Dusty String Crescendo 34, Help!

Posted In: Amateur Harpists

  • Participant
    unknown-user on #160604

    I currently play a Paki 29 rosewood harp and it has been a great entry to the harp world. But we are looking for a better harp. I love the looks of the L&H Shamrock

    Participant
    unknown-user on #160605

    Do you have any chance to play either?

    Participant
    Leigh Griffith on #160606

    Have you checked out other makes? I’m thinking of Blevins and Triplett, but there are others, too. Don’t rush into a decision, and save more while you are looking. I searched extensively for two years online while I was saving and then traveled to Somerset and played harps all day before I finally decided on mine. Blevins wasn’t at Somerset, so I didn’t get to try any of those, but I am happy with my Triplett Sierra 34. I didn’t like the Crescendo because it didn’t have the Camac levers, didn’t have the same resonance, and was harder for me to reach around (I have very short arms). Even with the slight “staving” of the back I could not reach the two lowest strings.

    I also think that with new, you aren’t inheriting previous bumps and dings whose consequences are yet to be seen. I don’t know what the warranty is on the CPO harps, but I do like Triplett’s seven year warranty.

    Just some stuff to consider.
    Happy hunting!
    Leigh

    Participant
    andy-b on #160607

    Hi, Dennis: I was just at the Atlanta Harp Center this weekend, and they have a Crescendo 34 in stock now for $2995, I believe it had been used as a rental harp. I haven’t tried a Shamrock, so I couldn’t tell you how the sound compares, but you could ask them

    Participant
    brook-boddie on #160608

    Dennis,

    I’ve played both a Shamrock and a Crescendo 34, and the sound of the Crescendo 34 was much nicer to my ears.

    Participant
    Jerusha Amado on #160609

    And as someone who owns one of Brook’s harps (a Dusty 36S with a beautiful, projecting tone) I can testify to the fact that he is a great judge of a harp’s sound.

    Jerusha

    Participant
    Michaela Braveman on #160610

    Hi Dennis,

    I can understand and relate to wanting a harp that not only sounds great, but is aesthetically pleasing as well, an I encourage you to not settle for a harp unless you find that both of your requirements are met (chances are too great that you won’t be happy with your purchase afterwards).

    I can’t speak for the two specific harp models you are considering. But I would encourage you to check out the Triplett Signature that was mentioned in another posting, because that is in EXCELLENT price for a full size, professional quality harp. Also, you might want to check out the Used Harps for Sale on this site. I just looked and found a used Thormahlen Cygnet for $3000. The Cygnets are very beautiful harps in both sound and looks, and again, that’s an excellent price.

    In my opinion, if you end up having to wait 8 months for harp which you don’t seem that excited about in the first place, why even go there? There is nothing wrong with buying a used harp, as long as it is in good condition and you like it. And with your budget, you may end up getting a lot more bang for your buck in the long run.

    Michaela

    Participant
    Audrey Nickel on #160611

    I’m curious as to why there is such a waiting time for the Dusty?

    Participant
    sidney-butler on #160612

    I vote for the Dusty.

    Participant
    Jerusha Amado on #160613

    Sidney,

    I recently played a Merlin R-Harp.

    Participant
    Michaela Braveman on #160614

    Did you see the Crescendo on the Harp Connection site: http://www.harpconnection.com/harpstore/harp-Crescendo.html

    Participant
    Maria Myers on #160615

    Leigh,

    I’ve heard and played a Triplett, and it was just great–in looks and sound.

    Member
    jennifer-buehler on #160616

    Another suggestion much closer to your price range is the Heartland Dreamweaver.

    Participant
    Audrey Nickel on #160617

    I have played a Crescendo (a friend has one, and my local music store also keeps one on the floor)…the sound is absolutely lucsious!

    Participant
    Audrey Nickel on #160618

    I have to add that the Dusties are no more “produced in the masses” than are the Lyon & Healies, the Tripletts, the Blevins, the Stoney Ends, the Heartlands, the William Rees’s, or any number of other fine instruments.

    Audrey

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 27 total)
  • The forum ‘Amateur Harpists’ is closed to new topics and replies.