How long to learn a new song?

Posted In: Amateur Harpists

  • Member
    Anna Lea on #161230

    I have been taking lessons a little over 2 1/2 years, could not read music and am a senior.

    Participant
    Audrey Nickel on #161231

    It’s going to vary a lot Anna, and there are going to be a lot of factors:

    1) The difficulty of the tune

    2) The difficulty of the arrangement

    3) How much time you have to devote to practice

    4) How involved you are with the tune (it’s a lot easier to learn a tune or an arrangement that you love!)

    5) Your own dexterity

    6) Your own, innate, ability to learn and retain music

    These are going to vary from harper to harper, and from circumstance to circumstance.

    Participant
    Karen Johns on #161232

    I agree with Audrey- it depends on several factors. On average it takes me about a week of one-hour practices to get the memorizing down, then a few more days to smooth it all out. Here is my basic

    Member
    tony-morosco on #161233

    Yeah, it really depends on what it is. Debussy? A very long time. One of Sylvia Woods arrangements? A week or two.

    When I learn a jazz piece it actually takes me the longest. I learn the basic piece, melody and basic accompaniment. But then I take a while to study the structure. The chord progression and the main intervals used and to what effect. I really need to get that under my skin and it takes a while. Then I have to play around with it for a while to get some ideas on which to build counter-melodies and to provide a basis to improvise over. The whole dissecting and analysing part takes longer than just learning the head and chords even though the actual reading of the music is often easier than reading a even one of Sylvia Woods ‘easy’ arrangements.

    My advice is to not judge yourself by other people in these things. We all have our strengths and weaknesses. Some people can sit down and play almost perfectly from the written page the first time though (and I admit I envy that ability), but they may have difficulty with memorization or problems playing by ear. Others can improvise an accompaniment for another player without even knowing ahead of time the structure of the piece, but can’t play from sheet music to save their lives.

    So don’t worry. Just work on the things you feel you need work on and in the process you will discover your strengths as well. We all have problems in one area or another, and we all shine in others.

    Member
    kay-lister on #161234

    Anna,

    I have found that there is some music that I don’t master while actually working on that particular piece.

    Participant
    sherry-lenox on #161235

    I absolutely agree with Kay 100% on this. I posted a similar experience to this in “Beginning In the Middle” yesterday.

    I sometimes prefer working on harder pieces a week or so more than my teacher wants me to work on them too, and she usually goes along with me on that, because she knows that I have a particular goal in mind with the piece.

    I am a retired certified music teacher who took up the harp two years ago this coming April.

    Participant
    WJMinDC@comcast.net on #161236

    Anna,

    Our harp playing colleagues have provided excellent counsel and encouragement.

    Participant
    rod-c on #161237

    Anna:

    I, too, have been taking lessons for just over two years, and I have noticed how long it takes to polish a piece.

    Participant
    Seoid OC on #161238

    How long it takes to learn a piece depends on how hard the piece is and how polished I want it to be.

    Member
    Anna Lea on #161239

    Thanks so very much to all of you for taking time to respond to my question.

    Participant
    unknown-user on #161240

    That is not a matter of time or hours – there are songs that are pretty easy to learn and you will take just a few days to learn them and others you wont know them after years. It is very hard to tell – it depends how you learn, how concentrated and how many songs at the same time …
    There is no answer for that sorry 🙂

    Participant
    Liam M on #161241

    How long? Well Twinkle Twinkle Little Star is still escaping me after a year…..

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • The forum ‘Amateur Harpists’ is closed to new topics and replies.