getting more reliable students

Posted In: Teaching the Harp

  • Participant
    Misty Harrison on #83393

    Does anyone have suggestions for getting more students who actually show up each week and pay on time? What works to get students and what have you tried that didn’t work at all or that attracted unreliables? students who don’t want to rent or buy a harp or only come 4 x’s a year, or never seem to bring their checkbook

    patricia-jaeger on #83394

    Misty, sorry I don’t have a clear answer, especially as it’s a recession now in the U.S. and many students are dropping out these days from private music lessons. One thing you could try, however, is contacting a nearby elementary school and offering a free mini-concert and demonstration of the harp. Such an educational approach might bring a new student to your door. At the very first encounter, then, (mine are free) you could explain honestly the demands and delights of learning to play harp. I include snips of DVDs of accomplished players as well as of a young player,

    Angela Biggs on #83395

    Misty, I only play (do not teach) harp – but I do teach voice. A very clear studio policy, and the willingness to stand your ground, really help with your problem.

    Common practice in a voice studio is to require a month (or sometimes two weeks) paid in advance, due at the first lesson of the period. People are much less likely to skip if they’ve already paid. Set a firm grace period in your head (not in your written studio policy) – you might let the student be one week late with payment twice a year, for example – and really stick to it. Say “no” if you must. “Mr. X, I have placed your lessons on hold until I receive payment. Your lesson for 3 PM tomorrow has been canceled. Once I receive a check, I would be happy to resume.”

    In fact, this is a perfect time of year to send out an email to all of your students with a PDF or Word doc clearly outlining your policies. For example: in a voice studio, a certain amount of notice is required if a student is going to miss a lesson and wants to reschedule it. If that student doesn’t give the minimum notice (such as 24 hours), he forfeits the fee he paid – at the beginning of the month – for that lesson. That way, the teacher is at least minimally compensated for the annoyance. And if the student wants to keep skipping and forfeiting, well, that’s his choice! Of course there are exceptions for emergencies, but “emergency” means emergency: it needs to involve an illness including fever, hospitalization of self or family member, or death in the family. I once had a student show up and my door and explain that her husband’s daughter stopped by and they were all going to go to the park! Not an emergency! lol

    Make sure to address your pet peeves. For example, since you don’t like it when students just drop in a few times a year, describe the level of commitment you require.

    If you have many students who are problems (and it sounds like you might), I would recommend that you ask everyone to sign the document to indicate understanding and acceptance, and get it back to you _before_ their next lesson. Settle on a grace period in your own head (such as one lesson), and stick to it. That’s the most important part. You need to stand firmly behind the policies you set. Keep some hard copies on your music stand for those who “forget” to bring it to that second lesson. As in, “Oh, don’t worry about it. I have some right here. Have you read it yet? No? Well, this is what it says. . .” Even read it to them word-for-word if you must, and then hand them the paper and a pen.

    Whether or not you need the income, you’re running a business. Don’t be afraid to act like a business-owner! 🙂 It can be hard, but just remember: friendly but firm.

    Best of luck!


    Saul Davis Zlatkovski on #83396

    My sister has concluded, from listening to my anecdotes, that the harp attracts a higher number of flaky people than other endeavors. Especially adults.

    Philippa mcauliffe on #83397

    Having watched the comings and goings of the adults (and children) of our own teacher over the last few years I think that there is a quite substantial

    Saul Davis Zlatkovski on #83398

    It is my impression that cities vary widely in their ability to produce harp students. Location seems to be one of the biggest factors, but also one of the most unpredictable, perhaps.

    J P on #83399

    I agree with the other poster about requiring payment in full for the month.

    Misty Harrison on #83400

    Thanks for all the advice. I do charge by the month but I have three students whose families seem to never be able to provide the money on time. I will have to use the “lessons on hold until payment received approach.” I usually try to talk to the parents in person but they drop the kids off when they need to pay and I can’t get to them before they’ve driven away. I’ll have to send a formal letter with a reminder of studio policy.

    Saul Davis Zlatkovski on #83401

    I have experienced people who feel free to take advantage of a harp teacher, either by lying or false bargaining. If they think you are weak, they will do it. Some have no respect. With some it must be ego, and then there are those with disorders. Some are snobs, elitist or otherwise, some boorish, some ill-mannered, and some are just mean. Thank goodness it is a (hopefully) minority who are this way.

    Philippa mcauliffe on #83402

    If you present yourself as very, very

    mr-s on #83403

    :(((( thats a sad story for me, i do look for a students for teaching the at the conservatory where i do work of course for free , and dont find, and i accept non musical background students too

    Saul Davis Zlatkovski on #83404

    Those techniques don’t seem to work on the kind of people I’ve encountered.

    patricia-jaeger on #83405

    Mr. S, You have discovered the main stumbling block between liking the sound and look of harps, and being able to take lessons on a harp: the expense. Couldn’t they start on a small harp, made in your country? They could be sold cheaply if partly finished, in “kit” form. The family of the prospective harp player could finish it at home. Experienced stringed instrument builders in your area could make the kits, perhaps after purchasing one to use as a model. The builders would make more sales, the family purchasing the small harp would help their student, the student gains new marketable playing skills, the teacher gains a new student–somehow, starting small and gradually arriving at a larger harp could be the way over that stumbling block. If you offer a group rate for young beginners, the talented ones in your group will soon be apparent to you. When a teacher offers a scholarship (free lessons for a short time) such motivated students will want to continue and they will find a way to pay your full rate. A number of years ago my local newspaper published a picture of a young woman as she worked for the company that collects garbage from homes. The woman interviewed said she took the well-paying job in order to buy a harp. Another young person delivered morning newspapers before going to school each day. At Conservatory for four years, I waited on tables for the three summers in between those years, at a fancy resort in New York State. Wealthy patrons at the resort left handsome tips for the waitresses and for the caddies on the golf course. My “tips” helped with tuition at my school.

    emily-mcintyre on #83406

    In ten years of teaching private piano lessons, I faced this dilemma many times. Eventually, I wrote up a studio contract which stated clearly each aspect of behavior in my studio, including payment and practicing expectations, then had the parents or adult student sign and date it at the first lesson. Every year or so I updated it and made sure everyone read it. This helped, to a large degree.

    I also became much pickier about who I accepted as a student, always scheduling a (free) interview first before committing to teaching. There are some dead giveaways for problem students.

    I hope you are able to figure it out!


    Dwyn . on #83407

    Perhaps you should try modifying your approach to fit the market.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 18 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.