harpcolumn

Please help me with my harp purchase!

Log in to your Harp Column account to post or reply in the forums. If you don’t have an account yet, you’ll need to email us to set one up.

Home Forums Harps and Accessories Please help me with my harp purchase!

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 20 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #283774
    Nicbo
    Participant

    Hello everyone, I’m new:)

    I have been planning on purchasing my first harp. I learned how to as a teenager on L&H, so I’m not a beginner but this will be my first harp.

    I have spoken to a harp store person about possibility of buying a new harp (since I haven’t been able to find a good used harp for last couple of years around here). Then I asked her if she could give me a discount if I pay in full, either with cash or check. She told me she could give me 3% discount.
    I have purchased other instruments in the past, cash, and I had a better luck with discount. I wasn’t too excited about 3% since it is quite a sum I’ll be paying in full. Then again I know nothing about harp market.

    Would anybody please give me your input? She might be thinking I’m rich and that I wouldn’t need any discount, but in fact this will be a great dent in our finance because we are not at all wealthy like it seems (to her.)

    Thank you!!

    #283777
    carl-swanson
    Participant

    For most musical instruments, the dealer discount is 50%. A Steinway dealer who is selling a Steinway for $100,000 bought it for $50,000! But for harps, the dealer discount is so small, usually 10% to 20%, that they simply cannot afford to discount the instrument. I’m surprised the dealer offered you a 3% discount.

    #283778
    Nicbo
    Participant

    Nice meeting you Carl Swanson and thank you for your input!

    How would you approach an issue like this? I am calling two other dealers and see what percentage of discount they’d offer and go from there, and see if my dealer can match that. But I haven’t heard back from neither stores.

    They wouldn’t have offered any discount if I hadn’t mentioned that. All this makes me wonder if they are even truthful about what they are selling and if I should trust them for years to come. I know it’s business, but great music can be achieved when the trust cis at the base of the relationship.

    If I negotiate, I don’t want to be contentious or threatening. If anybody knows a better approach, would you teach me how? What do you think, Carl? You have more experience in purchasing harps and you might now how harp dealers work, I am completely new in this field:{

    Thank you for reading!

    #283820
    balfour-knight
    Participant

    I will add my two cents here, ha, ha! Carl is correct, and I too am surprised that a harp dealer would offer you any discount. I expected to pay the full listed price for all of my harps over the years, and sometimes a nice dealer would include something like an accessory or shipping for free. Other times, when I was trading in a used harp for a new one, the dealer would give me a good, generous price on the trade-in. But remember, the harp dealers need to make enough money to stay in business, and it is not like some of the other instruments, guitars, violins, or pianos, where there is a larger market for those kinds of instruments. Also, harps are almost entirely hand-made, so that fact explains their greater expense, compared to factory-made instruments.

    I wish you the best in your harp purchase,
    Balfour

    #283821
    Nicbo
    Participant

    Nice meeting you, Balfour! Thank you for your two cents:)

    I probably shouldn’t feel too bad then that I’m not getting like 10% off. It’s good to know because I only know about purchasing smaller instruments and piano, and those are higher in demand like you said, and that makes sense.

    Thank you for your input! And I’ll report back when my harp comes in 5 months! (I have to purchase first, of course!)

    Nicbo

    #283827
    carl-swanson
    Participant

    “They wouldn’t have offered any discount if I hadn’t mentioned that. All this makes me wonder if they are even truthful about what they are selling and if I should trust them for years to come.”

    I’ve held off responding to your post until now, mainly because I found your second post quite offensive. The above quote, taken from that post, makes you sound pushy and disrespectful, and totally concerned with haggling over price. If you can’t afford a particular instrument, then buy a cheaper one. Or look for a used instrument that you can afford. But don’t blame and denigrate a dealer for a problem that is entirely yours.

    #283828
    charles-nix
    Member

    The concern with “not finding a used harp around here” brings up another point: sooner or later you will need a technician. If travelling to purchase a harp is a big deal–then don’t you really NEED the local dealer to stay in business? Harp technicians are generally even further away than you can find an instrument.

    Another consideration for you is that harps are relatively expensive to maintain, depending greatly on which type of harp we’re speaking of. If +/- 3% on the new price is a true problem, then you can’t afford the maintenance to own and keep one in good condition.

    And maybe that’s too harsh a statement–but all the techs and builders on here have seen numerous fine instruments reduced to complete junk by no maintenance or by attempts at cheap maintenance.

    #283829
    Biagio
    Participant

    I suppose it depends on what kind of harp is being considered but I will say that the margins for any good harp are slim for the builder as well as for a dealer. Cost of materials, overhead, labor and supply/demand keep a builder’s margin pretty low. For a lever harp maker such as Dusty Strings I would guess 10%-20% profit margin. They certainly would not give anyone a discount except in unusual circumstances e.g. on a prototype or an “orphan harp” like the one they made for Martha Gallagher.

    Which brings up another question: what kind of harp are you looking for? If you have not played for a long time it might be best to start out with something like Dusty’s Ravenna 34 or Musicmakers’ Voyageur. There is a ready second hand market for lever harps if you later decide to grade up to a concert (pedal) harp. For that matter if you might consider a Musicmakers kit if cost is a real worry and you can handle some simple wood working tasks.

    #283831
    Nicbo
    Participant

    Hi everyone,
    I’m sorry if I sounded like I did and cause people to be upset:'(
    The price is not the problem I was facing, it’s the fact that I didn’t know whether the dealer was being honest or not and I wouldn’t know because I have never bought a harp before. L&H I practiced on growing up was someone else’s.
    I have bought violin, piano, Clarinet in the past like I had mentioned, and they all told me if I paid in full they’d give a discount. With this harp purchase, they didn’t offer that until I had mentioned it, like many other hospitals, to me, they seemed to be withholding the information on pay in full for a small discount.

    I was being skeptical is all, no hard feelings. I don’t believe in “pay how much ever if you can afford it.”

    If you’d like me to delete my post, I will do so. Please let me know:'{

    Have a good day to you all.

    #283833
    Biagio
    Participant

    Don’t feel bad, you weren’t to know.

    The people here are really happy to help; you might wish to begin another thread telling us some details – your budget, type of harp desired, location etc.

    Best wishes,
    Biagio

    #283839
    balfour-knight
    Participant

    Hi, Nicbo,

    Yes, don’t feel bad. I think I understand better now, where you were coming from. If this were a used car, or maybe even a new one, it would pay to be very careful about the dealer’s price, and you could do a great deal of research to find out if it were a good price. With harps, it is different, as you will learn. There is no “Blue Book” of used harp prices! If dealing with purchasing a used harp, it is a very good idea to get a professional harp technician, like Carl Swanson, or just a knowledgeable person you trust, to look over the harp to make sure everything is okay. It is like getting a good car mechanic to do the same thing for a used car. If it is a new harp, it should come with a nice warranty. You will come to understand this better as you go along in your harp journey. All of us here had to learn the same things!

    Again, best wishes in your harp purchase,
    Balfour

    • This reply was modified 4 years, 6 months ago by balfour-knight. Reason: clarity
    #283874
    balfour-knight
    Participant

    P. S. to what I wrote above:

    Nicbo, I do hope you will indeed let us know more about the harp you intend to purchase, like Biagio said. In the USA, I can heartily recommend Pacific-Atlantic Harps in CA, The Virginia Harp Center, and the Atlanta Harp Center. The individual lever harp makers, like Dusty Strings, Thormahlen Harps, Musicmakers Harps, Rees Harps, Pratt Harps, and several others are also very nice folks to work with, and they are all very talented harp makers. I recommend three pedal harp makers, Camac, Lyon and Healy, and Salvi. You can get on-line to compare prices of new harps and used harps. Harp Column also advertises pre-owned harps in the Classified section, and occasionally, new harps.

    I hope we have been of some help to you, and please continue to post here.

    Cheers and best regards,
    Balfour

    • This reply was modified 4 years, 6 months ago by balfour-knight. Reason: typo!
    #283876
    Nicbo
    Participant

    Balfour knight,

    Thank you for reaching out to me! I was a bit paranoid about posting again, I was hoping to make friends here and it seemed like what I wrote above did exactly the opposite, but I don’t even know how to delete posts either. I’m so behind on technology!

    I’m now looking into Camac Egerie, the one you can regulate on your own. I knew finding a harp technician would not be easy so even though I know Salvi, Lion and Healy and all the other make great instruments, I was very interested in camac because of its user friendliness. (Assuming that I can learn to use the kit!)

    I’m a bit nervous about Egerie because it is new and I’m not finding many sound samples and that the dealers here in Washington don’t have Egerie at their stores for me to try.

    I’d like to make a new post and ask people what they think of it if they have Egerie, but I’m a bit scared to do so haha what if I say something wrong again and make people upset? Is rather want to keep to myself because I hate contention and I don’t want to be the one to create that environment even if it wasn’t intended.

    Thank you Balfour:) Thank you!

    #283877
    balfour-knight
    Participant

    Hi again, Nicbo!

    So good to see and read your post above! Thanks for letting us know that you are interested in the Egerie by Camac. I am one of Camac’s biggest fans, and own a gorgeous Atlantide Prestige. I “grew up” on Lyon and Healy, and owned several nice harps made by them, but I now am a “Camac artist,” ha, ha! At many of my former concerts, L&H harps have been provided for me, but now I take my Camac, or ask for a comparable Camac, if taking my own harp is too inconvenient.

    I do love that I can regulate this harp all by myself, even though it is such a fine instrument that it requires very little adjustment. I have owned it since 2017, and it was professionally regulated by Liza Jensen of Camac. The manual of instructions is very good, and if you are good with your hands at this sort of thing, you will be able to regulate the harp yourself. It is very important to study the manual and know that Camacs regulate differently than other brands of harps. You can read about some of the Camac “differences” on the website of Pacific-Atlantic Harps, Carolyn Sykes.

    On the main website of Camac, there are wonderful concerts by some very famous harpists, and you can find one by Sylvain Blassel done on an Egerie. It is gorgeous! I have not yet had the pleasure of playing a new Egerie, but I hear from some of my friends that they are very nice! You would have a full-size 47 string concert grand harp which would be capable of playing ALL of the harp repertoire.

    Enjoy your harp journey, my new friend. The harp is the most beautiful instrument in existence!

    Kind regards,
    Balfour

    #283879
    Nicbo
    Participant

    Oh Balfour, thank you so much for your input, website information and encouragement! I have visited camac website but I haven’t looked in deep enough to find that performance, so I will now!
    And wow, you must be quite a performer! If you have played many harps and ended up choosing camac, then I won’t have any reason to hesitate anymore:D Of course it won’t be as awesome as Atlantide but still!!

    I might end up moving to Idaho or Montana near future, and I thought if we don’t have many technicians here, I’ll have even slimmer chance of finding one over there because it’s less populated compared to here in Seattle. So being able to regulate your own harp sure is a big factor for me. I’ll do my best to read the entire manual. I tend to avoid reading manuals in general, but I will do so for my harp:}

    Thank you again Balfour! I have another question but I will make a different thread so this thread doesn’t get too long!

    And thank you Carl Swanson, Charles-nix and Biagio, for you guys’ wisdom. I appreciate you reading my post and taking time to respond!!
    Have a good night!

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 20 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.