Home › Forums › Harps and Accessories › String Tension Comparison
- This topic has 7 replies, 4 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 4 months ago by
patricia-jaeger.
-
AuthorPosts
-
April 24, 2014 at 5:04 pm #78320
Jodi Ann Tolman
ParticipantI understand how different brands and models of harps have different string tensions, and I understand that the tension is all relative, but would anyone be able to list several popular lever harp makes and models in order of string tension–highest to lowest?
If you’re able, try to include:
-L&H Troubadour/Ogden/Prelude,
-Thormahlen Swan/Serenade
-Dusty Strings FH36
-Triplett Sierra
-Merlin R Harp
and any other popular lever harps.I only have experience playing on my rented Troubadour and my teacher’s Prelude, but I’m very interested in the Thormahlens. I’ve heard the L&Hs are more tightly strung than most other lever harps, but its hard to understand really what “loose” tension or “medium” tension means relatively. I’d like to get a harp that is maybe looser than the Troubadour but still is able to put out good volume.
April 24, 2014 at 7:21 pm #78321Jodi Ann Tolman
ParticipantSo after reading a bit more online, I’m understanding that it’s not so much the brand of the harp that determines the string tension, but the type of string the harp is strung with. Is that true?
So it sounds like concert gut is the highest tension,
Nylon is medium tension, just lighter than concert gut,
Lever Gut is lighter tension than Nylon,
and Fluorocarbon have the lightest tension.Is that correct?
April 24, 2014 at 8:00 pm #78322Tacye
ParticipantThere are two aspects to tension. What a harpist calls tension is often how hard you can/need to pull on the strings – so a very responsive harp will be perceived as lower tension even thought the pull on the strings between tuning peg and soundboard, which a physicist calls tension, is the same.
For a given pitch the physical tension will depend on the length and mass of the string. If you have two harps of different sizes but the same strings the one with longer strings will need the higher tension to pull each string to pitch.
Also, a more massive string will need more tension to bring it to a given pitch. Mass (or more precisely mass for a given length) of string can be altered in two main ways. Firstly by changing the thickness of the string. Concert gut is thicker than lever gut so higher tension. Similarly concert fluorocarbon is thicker than lever fluorocarbon and higer tension. Different materials also have different densities so changing a string from nylon to one *of the same thickness* in the more dense fluorocarbon will increase the tension. However, harpists usually don’t buy strings by thickness and if you buy a middle C string in nylon and one in fluorocarbon the nylon one will be thicker. Any harpbuilder who wanted to could make high, low or medium tension harps strung in any of the three materials mentioned.
April 24, 2014 at 11:13 pm #78323Jodi Ann Tolman
ParticipantThat is a fabulous explanation. Thank you!
April 30, 2014 at 9:18 pm #78324sheri-wildt
ParticipantFor comparison, I’ve played the Prelude, Troubador and a Stoney End lever harp. The L&H harps had a higher tension in my opinion. They sounded really good but definitely required more work, so to speak. I didn’t want a big whopping harp to cart around, however, so I opted for the Stoney End Briar Rose. I would say the tension is medium. It also sounds really good, and is easier to pull the strings than the L&H harps, but it isn’t floppy or light in tension at all. They also have a fantastic rent to own program at Stoney End and I highly recommend their harps! The Briar Rose is a smaller floor harp, but it’s easier to transport than a bigger harp. It’s still a bit awkward though, just because of the shape/size.
I currently have a loaner lap harp that has really light tension. I don’t know who made it.. someone in Tennessee. It has a very consistent tone and sounds fine, but the tension seems very loose and I tend to overplay it. I don’t care for it and prefer a closer to medium tension feel.
May 2, 2014 at 9:38 pm #78325patricia-jaeger
MemberRegarding string tension: I have a small flat metal gauge for string diameter measurement in millimeters made by Elton company, that was about $4.00. It has been so useful over the years, for replacing a broken string with one that has the same diameter. All string players could benefit this way, having such a gauge, but I wonder if anyone here knows a source for them these days?
May 3, 2014 at 11:24 am #78326Tacye
ParticipantPatricia, you can get cheap micrometers which are useful for strings and all sorts of other things from most budget tool sources (eg ebay). Plain wire gauges are available too, but usually marked up with gauge numbers so easier to use for comparison than recording a measurement in mm or 001″.
May 3, 2014 at 4:06 pm #78327patricia-jaeger
MemberTacye, Thank you so much! I will look into those choices.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.


