harpcolumn

Burgandy vs Bow Strings, or other

Log in to your Harp Column account to post or reply in the forums. If you don’t have an account yet, you’ll need to email us to set one up.

Home Forums Harps and Accessories Burgandy vs Bow Strings, or other

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #74407
    Barbara Henniger
    Participant

    I have ordered my first harp ( a Prelude40) and am getting everything in order for its arrival! I am very excited but still looking for more advice.

    I have ordered the travel covers and harp but am shopping around for my replacement strings. I am hoping to place the order soon enough to have the strings when the harp arrives. Is there anything else I should also order with the harp that I may not have thought of?

    I have come across different brands of strings and want to know what experienced players think about the differences in the different brands. I have been playing a year and practise about 1 hour a day.

    #74408
    barbara-low
    Participant

    Vanderbilt Classic Gut – best bang for the buck, as the saying goes. They have a warmer tone than Bow Brands. Vanderbilt Music sells both the Classic, Burgundy and Bow Brand gut strings, which makes it easier to compare prices.

    I’d get an extra tuning key. The ergonomic ones are very nice and they work if you hold them correctly. Use the handle like a lever; like you’re drawing beer on tap.

    Congratulations and enjoy your new harp.

    Barbara in CA

    #74409
    Jerusha Amado
    Participant

    I once had my Salzedo strung with Vanderbilt Burgundy gut strings, and they gave it a wonderful sound.

    #74410
    Donna O
    Participant

    I have a Prelude 40 and use Vanderbilt Classic Gut.

    #74411
    paul-wren
    Participant

    I have never understood what the difference between Bow and Burandy was…. they are both Bow Brand strings. Maybe the only real difference is the price??

    Vanderbilt classics are good strings and yes a good bang for the buck! I keep a full set of Vanderbilt for replacements.

    #74412
    andy-b
    Participant

    If I remember correctly, the Burgandy strings are cheaper because they may have visual imperfections – nothing that’s supposed to affect the sound.

    Andy

    #74413
    Jerusha Amado
    Participant

    Andy,

    This is what I have heard as well.

    #74414

    I used to use Burgundy gut strings for years, when they came from Lyon & Healy. In more recent years, they were of much less quality, not good enough to keep, much more than just visual imperfections. I went back to Bow, despite the cost. I used two sets of Classic gut and found them hard to keep in tune, not clear in pitch, and the protective coating is so thin it wore off very quickly. Pirastro strings may be the best, but soooo expensive. I use Pirastro nylon strings for 0-3 octaves, then Bow gut, and silver/copper wires, no colored strings.

    #74415
    Tacye
    Participant

    I find that some different brands of strings sound slightly different and it often irritates me to have one different string in the middle of an octave.

    #74416
    Jerusha Amado
    Participant

    This is interesting, Saul.

    #74417
    paul-wren
    Participant

    I have to say that I dont like the Burgandy and wont even waste my money on them.

    I have never bought Pirastro’s because of the cost of them, but have heard many harpist that have Salvi harps just love them. Maybe because of the tension.

    #74418

    It might have been then. I believe that Lyon & Healy originally sold them, and then it was switched over to Bow Brand, as they’ve been around a long time. I used them from about 1985 to 2005.

    #74419

    I’ve mentioned in other posts that I switched my 1 – 3 octaves on my Apollo to nylon (I had Bow brand on before that). About two months ago I got fed up with the things NEVER keeping pitch and having a constantly split right thumb, so I switched again to Vanderbilt Classic. The sound is so beautiful I can’t stop practicing, they’re easy on my hands, they hold pitch like a dream, and my thumb healed within a week. I’ll never stray from gut again, and Vanderbilt will be it!!!!

    #74420
    Barbara Henniger
    Participant

    Thank you everyone, for all the feedback. I feel I can make an informed decision now.

    My new Prelude40 is waiting in Vancouver for me to pickup and arrived much sooner than I expected. I am thrilled and think of nothing else but my harp right now!

    My other concern is what is the shelf life of gut strings and how should I store my spare set?

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.