harpcolumn

Anything you are not keen on ??

Log in to your Harp Column account to post or reply in the forums. If you don’t have an account yet, you’ll need to email us to set one up.

Home Forums Repertoire Anything you are not keen on ??

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #61929
    Alison
    Participant

    just as I thought I’d get back into playing, well, we are doing “In the South”. This is the 3rd time that I have been given this piece in 15 years and d’ya know, I just can’t bring myself to like it. There’s so much Elgar that I know & love but but this one… Curiously, since I also play brass and usually I like their ensemble. I guess this is just one piece that will never speak to me even though some of it is indeed lyrical.
    Maybe this has been explored before:
    http://www.harpcolumn.com/forums/coffee-break/posts/24813

    #61930
    Sherri Matthew
    Participant

    Hi Alison,

    Thanks for posting the link, it was an interesting read! I don’t play pedal harp so I’m not familiar with the piece you mentioned… maybe a link to a good example of it?

    On wire harp I started with the traditional Irish folk music… I still appreciate it but I dont’t play it at all anymore. My work now revolves entirely around arranging Gregorian chant for wire harp. It was a good way to learn the basics of technique, but mine has evolved a lot to accomodate playing chant, so it’s not at all historically correct anymore… Not a question of like/dislike per se, just my own musical growth and development. I doubt I could go back to playing, say, jigs and reels in a truly authentic way on harp now. Once in a great while I’ll give a listen to someone else doing that, say to myself, “oh, yes I remember that one” and then it’s back to chant studies.

    #61931
    Sylvia
    Participant

    One I thought of right away….is the Sousa Stars and Stripes. I make major modifications. Tempo is 138, and I’d dearly love to see someone play the part as written at that tempo! No one cares, of course, and the section that shows is the third section, which is OK for the arpeggios, and then deteriorates into (loud) madness, again requiring modifications. The part is not attributed to Sousa, although he always had a harpist in his band.

    #61932
    Sid Humphreys
    Participant

    About 4 year ago, I did Chadwick’s Symphonic Sketches. I didn’t care for the harp part at all. It was difficult to learn and could hardly be heard, except for the Noel; that was the hardest, I think the harp was playing 6 notes to the violins 4. Bleh! I hate remembering that performance! LOL

    #61933
    Alison
    Participant

    oh, well I will look up Chadwick, as never heard of him(?) – they said the harp sounded lovely and was ‘indespensible’ – & I’ve just renewed 25 new strings on it – my reading and playing were accurate and musical, so I guess the best thing about the day was being with friends… perhaps I will get payback unexpectedly.

    #61934
    roy-clement
    Member

    Sylvia, I have just taken on learning all of the Sousa Marches. I play a lot in Wind Ensembles and the Harp part always goes unplayed. ( I am a Percussionist, and a new Harpist.) I would love to hear more about your modifications to the Stars and Stripes! And, any other band works for that matter. Thanks!

    #61935
    Sylvia
    Participant

    I don’t write out stuff, so here’s my verbal account of S&S.
    My part says “Edited in Sousa performance style by Keith Brion,” so I don’t know if that’s what you have.

    For the first few years, I didn’t play the intro because it starts so fast, but then I got the hang of it to watch for the start and still focus. (slow learner)
    Here’s Syl’s cheat sheet.

    M3 omit G♮ and A♮
    M5-12 LH top notes only and connected
    M12-13, LH top notes only
    M15-16 19-20 use LH octaves
    M15-16 2nd beat (we’re in cut time) RH B and A♮ together (omit LH on that beat)
    M21-36 LH top notes only RH chord scrunches (if it’s spread out, play closest
    chord members
    M54-85 as is…85 just a chord
    M86-87 forget it
    M88- RH only
    M89 1st beat
    M90-91 forget it
    M92 2nd beat RH
    M93-94 as is
    M95 1st beat only
    M96 forget
    M97 beat 2 only
    M98 as is
    M99 1st beat only
    M100-101 forget
    M102-105 as is
    M106-109 forget it
    Sections are repeated, so I use only the 1st page and the page starting with rehearsal #54. (no page turns)

    #61936
    Sylvia
    Participant

    This was on http://www.naxos.com
    Notice the third paragraph about instrumentation. I don’t know if that means he did NOT write for brass band.

    Sousa’s Greatest Marches

    John Philip Sousa personified turn-of-the-century America, the comparative innocence and brash energy of a still new nation. His ever touring band represented America across the globe and brought music to hundreds of American towns. John Philip Sousa, born 6th November, 1854, reached this exalted position with startling quickness. In 1880, at the age of 26, he became conductor of the U.S. Marine Band. In twelve years the vastly improved ensemble won high renown and Sousa’s compositions earned him the title of “The March King”. Sousa went one better with the formation of his own band in 1892, bringing world acclaim.

    In its first seven years the band gave 3500 concerts; in an era of train and ship travel it logged over a million miles in nearly four decades. There were European tours in 1900, 1901, 1903, and 1905, and a world tour in 1910–11, the zenith of the band era.

    The unprecedented popularity of the Sousa Band came at a time when few American orchestras existed. From the Civil War to about 1920, band concerts were the most important aspect of U.S. musical life. No finer band than Sousa’s was ever heard. Sousa modified the brass band by decreasing the brass and percussion instruments, increasing its woodwinds, and adding a harp. His conducting genius attracted the finest musicians, enabling him to build an ensemble capable of executing programs almost as varied as those of a symphony orchestra. The Sousa Band became the standard by which American bands were measured, causing a dramatic upgrading in quality nationally.

    #61937

    Sid, a harp performance in a summer orchestra I had to do, is one I wish I could forget. The conductor had programmed an Heroic March by Edvard Grieg, and I really don’t think Grieg had any harpist help him write the harp part- the pedaling demanded too many changes too quickly, and the brass and winds covered a lot anyway. Two weeks to practice the part was not enough for me. Has anyone else here played a harp part or work by Grieg? To quote you, Bleh!

    #61938
    Sid Humphreys
    Participant

    Patricia, maybe you’ll get a chance to do Saint-Saens ‘Marche Heroique.’ Much better for the harp!

    #61939
    justin-lo
    Participant

    There was a contemporary piece played in my orchestra 2 years ago, where the harp had to play a whole lot of 5 (on the left hand) against 3. Probably half a page, at least. I might have appeared a bit too overjoyed to learn that I’d be playing the piano part instead. But so far my encounters with contemporary orchestral music harp parts have never ended up favourably.

    #61940
    Sid Humphreys
    Participant

    Right now I am doing Suk’s “Fairytale” first movement. It’s like 6 pages of hard exercises. I’m really tempted to do E major glisses for half a measure with a C natural for the other half coming down. This goes on for 6 pages ( 2 sextuplets ascending followed by 2 sets of 16th descending). LOL!

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.