harpcolumn

String question

Log in to your Harp Column account to post or reply in the forums. If you don’t have an account yet, you’ll need to email us to set one up.

Home Forums Harps and Accessories String question

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #76293
    Andelin
    Participant

    I read somewhere (I don’t remember where now) that you can buy a skeleton set of strings, that only has about every other string. This got me thinking…how far away from the intended spot could you/would you put a string? If you can put a D string in the E spot just above it, how far away from the intended spot could that D string be put? Obviously putting strings in the wrong spots isn’t ideal; I’m asking more as a hypothetical, “in a pinch” sort of situation. I guess it might depend on the kind of pinch you’re in, and the string in question. 🙂 I wondered what more experienced harpists would have to say on the subject.

    So here’s a story you might find funny. (It’s not funny to me yet. Maybe I’ll be able to laugh about this in a few days.) Yesterday I noticed I had a string break (I knew it would break one of these days) so this morning I decided to change it. Just as I was about to start, the baby wakes up. But I decide to change it anyway. Right in the middle of it, I discover that my 3 year old had scattered the contents of a box of little things (too hard to explain what it was), and a few minutes later my 5 year old announced that his little brother had wet his pants all over my coffee table. And of course, the baby is crying during all of this. This all happened in about 3 minutes. Then I found my tuning key (the kids like to play with it, who knows why), and someone had taken a glue stick to it, so it was a sticky mess. I finally got the string changed, but it was a little dicey there for a while. *sigh* It seems today just isn’t turning out to be a good day for practicing harp.

    #76294

    LOL! I can sympathize! I have three kids of my own and have been there!

    I always keep an entire set of strings on hand. Right now I couldn’t afford to replace a whole set of strings so would probably replace my replacements one at a time as needed.

    As far as string tolerance for being out of range, I think it depends on what the string is made out of and where in the range of the harp it is. I’ve strung one of my harps with flourocarbon strings and a few are at the outer edge of the vibrating length. I definitely couldn’t use them on any higher pitches.

    I know on my main harp, several pitches use the same diameter string anyway. Check your string chart!

    #76295
    Tacye
    Participant

    There are two main issues with putting strings in the wrong position. Firstly the risk of damaging the harp, and secondly the likelihood of sounding bad, or really different from the rest of the harp.

    Damaging the harp: You can put strings which are thinner than idea on with little risk as the tension on the instrument will be less. There is a slight issue that if you left several consecutive strings with really light tension compared to the others for a long time the soundboard might take on a slightly uneven shape. However, the only time I have seen an uneven soundboard the harp in question had been sitting with only a few strings on it for 50 years or so. Putting heavier strings on will increase the tension on the harp and whether the harp can take it depends on the harp, how much heavier, how many and for how long. Putting pedal gauge strings on a Grecian Erard instead of the right ones (which are about lever gauge) is the equivalent of moving all the strings about 5 places thicker and is known to eventually pull the harp to pieces. I am not sure about time scales: anecdotally some seem to survive for some years, others don’t. Some harps will withstand much higher increases in tension (I inflicted a major one on a Stoney End Eve and it seems to be surviving fine). Individual strings again depend on the harp, but the overall tension is less likely to cause problems – changing the lowest guts for wires is possible and unlikely to cause soundboard distortion as there is already a tension change between the gut and the wire.

    Sound and feel: I notice a slight change when I put a string one out of step but soon adjust and am not sure I would notice if I didn’t know my own harp so well. I have also come across students unbothered by the fact that they have accidentally restrung an octave out.

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.