Home › Forums › Harps and Accessories › Lyon and Healy Prelude Alternate Strings
- This topic has 6 replies, 5 voices, and was last updated 1 week ago by
charles-nix.
-
AuthorPosts
-
April 6, 2025 at 11:14 am #422673
Robbie Laughlin
ParticipantHello! I have recently switched to a Lyon and Healy Prelude 40, having previously owned a Salvi Una.
I was wondering if anyone else has owned a Prelude and tried different strings on it, and had thoughts to share? I would be curious to hear your experience stringing this harp with lever gut instead of pedal gut, or perhaps with pedal tension SilkGut or BioCarbon strings. Do any of those options give a fuller sound, or make the harp sound brighter?
I’ve not yet purchased a set of replacement strings, as I’m fortunate enough to live close to a store that seems to have most individual pedal harp strings in stock, so I’m looking at alternate string options for the future, to see what else I might discover.
Many thanks!
April 6, 2025 at 3:48 pm #422743Saul Davis Zlatkovski
ParticipantYou should string it in accordance with the manufacturer, which is to say, pedal wire, gut and nylon strings.
April 6, 2025 at 4:01 pm #422750balfour-knight
ParticipantI agree with Saul, string it the way L&H says to.
April 7, 2025 at 7:33 am #422944charles-nix
ParticipantAbsolutely string what the manufacturer says. If you use too light tension, they will likely not have enough power to energize the thicker soundboard, which is made to hold pedal tension strings.
Also, if you change string gauges, the harp will have to re-settle in, and need a complete regulation. It is an expensive experiment, and you need to be clear on the goal and how realistic the goal is.
If by “fuller” you mean just more gross volume, probably nothing but a larger harp will help. That is a very different request from “brighter”.
Brighter (somewhat) you could probably achieve with a custom set of fluorocarbon. They would be smaller gauge at the same tension. You need to be able to calculate string gauging, restring the harp, wait six weeks for everything to settle in while tuning every day, then completely re-regulate the harp. It would all probably cost near $1000 to have a tech do it. It would work to some extent, because the tension is still the same, but the string diameter is smaller. You would also have a harp probably worth a bit less on the market because it wasn’t standard any more.
If you don’t like the sound of the harp, either correct your technique (if that’s the problem) or find a harp you do like the sound of.
April 7, 2025 at 8:02 am #422951Robbie Laughlin
ParticipantThanks everyone! I will stick to factory stringing. One of the issues I had was the cost of a string set here in Canada. It was well over $1000.
I did some more searching of the forums, and discovered I have several options, which include considering the premiere gut strings, which are offered in a set for the prelude, or just ordering from harp.com
Both these options lower the cost of a spare set of strings significantly for me, by almost half!
April 7, 2025 at 4:44 pm #423058Gregg Bailey
ParticipantCharles,
Why and how is Salvi able to offer the Ana in both pedal- and lever-gauge stringing?
Are both versions of the Ana equally successful? Are the strings the only difference between the two versions? Are Ana owners able to go back-and-forth between the two types of stringing?
-Gregg
April 8, 2025 at 8:48 am #423258charles-nix
ParticipantGregg, I’ve not examined either Ana. But the same model harp need only specify that it “looks” the same: same angles, same neck, etc. And the strings lengths for a given pitch are the same (ideally) regardless of the diameter of the string. So, you can certainly change the stringing gauge, while tuning to the same pitches, without any problem of breaking strings, or having them too flabby sounding. (assuming we’re talking about identical string material in both cases)
They could, certainly, build the lever soundboard thinner, to let it be more resonant, since it doesn’t have to support as much tension. Whether they do or not is a different matter. Lever gauge will absolutely resonate a thicker soundboard–just not at as much volume, but probably not a huge difference. Both production cost and market segment they are aiming at would be part of what they are considering. Maybe they offer the lever option so that young children can still get a good pluck, and then change to pedal gauge as the student grows older and has stronger fingers and better technique.
-
I’m not saying they do any of that
— I have no idea — but it sounds like a reasonable approach for a harp marketed to beginning students looking to progress to pedal harp. (And that is exactly the way they describe that model on their website.)
Dusty strings has models that can be strung multiple ways. The soundboard thickness thing isn’t an absolute issue for working/not working — it is just getting an ideal “biggest” sound from a gauging — and I’ll bet that a soundboard that doesn’t ever break under warranty is much more important to a manufacturer’s interest than one that has the last few percent of the “biggest” sound possible.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.