We have a different definition of Bad, Maria. To me
“Do we dare have a thread on who we think is the worst harp player? ” and “Too bad we can’t post anonymously”
is pretty clear and doesn’t need any assuming. It is inviting us to hold people up for public ridicule. How “amiable” is that? The made-up stuff (if it IS made up) came days later when the thread was going nowhere.
You’ll probably like the Mean Girls thread too.